Who Gives This Woman to be Married?

Derrick Coyle

Derrick Coyle

The language of religious tradition and the social advances of generations create an interesting juxtaposition when the two come together in modern day ceremony. Last Saturday, my wife and I had the honour of responding together, “we do” when asked, “who gives this woman to be married to this man?”

Long gone – at least in this part of the world – are the societal and proprietary customs under which the language was predicated centuries ago. But on this special day, the answer to the question posed by The Reverend Canon Janet Lynall at the historic and intimate St. Anne’s Anglican Church in (Byron) London, Ontario, made a pair of parental respondents very proud.

Erin & Dave – May 10, 2014

It also sent the father of the bride – after a beautiful ceremony and wonderful reception on a picture-perfect Spring day – into sentimental reflection on the process of courtship and the traditions of marriage. As the father of two married daughters, this is the second time I have taken my share of responsibility as a partyย who gives this woman to be married to this man. Out of the ensuing introspection, I’ve developed a few thoughts on the notion of dating and marriage from the perspective of a father of daughters.

*************************

It likely comes as no surprise that fathers tend to be a little protective of daughters once they reach the stage when suitors enter the picture. I know this from having been a participant on both sides of the equation. I married a woman from a family of four daughters and a son, almost 33 years ago, and there is a certain screening process that comes into play. The primary evaluator is usually the father, though in his absence or through his delegation, responsibilities may fall to other family members to assess the candidate in their own specific area of interest or expertise.

Either way, the father (or surrogate) is usually an integral component of prospect scrutiny, the weight of which a future son-in-law will have to successfully bear. And who can blame us? After two or three decades of supporting, teaching, encouraging, consoling, advising, celebrating, cautioning, sharing, caring, laughing with, learning from, protecting, and above all, loving daughters, a father does not take lightly the idea of subcontracting these responsibilities.

WhoGivesThisWoman2In my case, father-in-law, Romeo – a combination of very French and very vocal – was theย chief scrutineer. For the first few months, each visit to the family homestead in Pickering would be a test. Post-dinner, rec room conversation among the large family, involved Romeo taking his position on the couch directly opposite and staring intently at me, a semi-skittish swain. The penetrating gaze and impermeable interest was locked in, regardless of who in the room happened to be speaking at the time.

As a new entrant trying to make a good impression, there were boundaries to be carefully considered: physical spacing between daughter and me (close, but not smothering); choice of language (colourful, but not offensive); aptitude (knowledgeable, but not argumentative); and personality (humourous and mildly opinionated, but not buffoonish or cocky).

Romeo was a master of assessment through gut feel and between us there was a warm bond of respect and loving kinship from those early days, to his passing in 2009.

*************************

Adam & Sara – August 6, 2011

As members of fairly large families, on both my wife’s side and my own, potential boyfriends of my daughters were subject to multiple levels of quality control: The pre-qualification by various members of the extended family, and; the all-important approval by the patriarch – who may well be guided by family feedback but as Head of the Admissions Committee, is ultimately responsible for final endorsement.

Indeed, a few hard lessons (which may be of some future use to young readers) were learned by candidates eliminated in the early relationship rounds, many years ago:

  • Never borrow the father’s guitar if your fashion accessories include a large, abrasive belt buckle
  • It is ill-advised to arrive in the driveway of insurance industry parents, in a vehicle with tread-bare tires
  • Under no circumstances correct the French language accuracy of the girlfriend’s fluently French uncles at the family New Year’s Eve party

In the case of the two fine young men who married my daughters, the exercise was virtually stress-free and painless from the perspective of the father of the bride. Both cases involved long courtships and each eventual son-in-law quickly formed solid relations and friendships with grandparents, uncles, aunts, cousins, as well as the mother and father. Their interests aligned and personalities meshed nicely with the extended family. In both circumstances we got to know the boyfriend’s parents and could clearly see they were raised in households with the same core values we grew up with and sought to instill in our own family.

In the case of my oldest daughter, Sara, her boyfriend, Adam lived directly behind us. We had known his family since the kids were in elementary school and gotten on well with his parents for years. While this may not have been ideal for Adam, it was immensely convenient for a dating daughter’s parents.

Similarly, Erin’s husband, Dave’s parents are members of the same golf club we attend and we have formed a warm friendship with them in recent years.

We consider ourselves very fortunate in both cases, to not only experience the truth of the old adage: “you’re not losing a daughter, you’re gaining a son,” but to gain also the camaraderie and friendship of the broader families.

*************************

With a closing line pulled from the Traditional Irish Blessing chosen by the bride and groom as part of their wedding ceremony, a heartfelt wish for the newlyweds of whom we are so proud:

May you know nothing but happiness from this day forward

ย *************************

Feel Free to Share!

Shares

16 comments

  1. Hi Derrick, a great perspective on an ever evolving process. It is great that we have reached a point where a daughter’s happiness and shared core values over-ride the considerations of material gain or status that influenced “who gives this woman” for much of human history and which are still prevalent elsewhere. I like the way you relate your own experience as suitor to that of the prospective son-in-law and the failure of the unsuccessful candidates to put themselves in the panel’s shoes !

    • DC says:

      Thanks Paul. It was interesting going through the process and realizing things had come full circle. I gained a greater appreciation – once the young contenders started showing up – for the well-intentioned scrutiny of my father-in-law.

  2. Tim says:

    Did you ever see the movie “Father of the Bride”. Sounds like your experience in this situation was polar opposite and you summed it up beautifully. I will likely never go through this from your end but have been on the receiving end many times in the past; the prospective suitor part. On all but one occasion I got along with the parents. On the exception, father approached me with a shot gun. That was the last time I went out with his daughter ๐Ÿ™‚

    • DC says:

      Loved the Steve Martin version! Yes, I’m grateful to have had relatively smooth sailing, though I can remember the same sentiment of daughters growing up too quickly. Sounds like your priority adjustment was pretty reasonable given the homicidal father and his brand of persuasion. Thanks for your comments.

  3. Congratulations on what was clearly a welcome change for your family. I must admit to laughing and cringing at the belt buckle… ouch. ๐Ÿ™‚ I loved my own in-laws dearly and felt their loss as keenly as if they had been my own parents, so fully agree with you that marriage reallly is about extending your family (if you pick the right candidate).

    • DC says:

      Thanks Debra. It was a true celebration and perfect day in the cases of both daughters. I know exactly what you mean about the bond with in-laws and the impact of their loss. Appreciate your comments.

  4. Lenie says:

    Hi Derrick – totally enjoyed reading this post – you have a wonderful way with words and brought back memories, some chuckles, some feeling of gratitude about my own children’s spouses and families and just the feeling of the strength of the family.
    Lenie

    • DC says:

      Hi Lenie, thanks very much for your kind comments. Sounds like we share an appreciation for the good fortune of family.

  5. I enjoyed reading this very much. Thank you for sharing your personal experience as “father of the bride”!

    I like the Irish blessing too!

    • DC says:

      Thanks so much Karoly. I’m off to Ireland in a couple of weeks so you may be in for some more Irish gems in future posts. ๐Ÿ™‚

  6. What a beautiful story and must admit that it brought a tear to my eye. My father passed when I was 17 so never got to make that walk down the aisle with him. But it also made me laugh because when I was dating in high school, his tactic was to sit opposite my date and just stare at him. It was dreadful! BUT…also endearing:) It’s wonderful that your family has grown…especially with people that you really care about. Congratulations!

    • DC says:

      Thanks for your comments Jacqueline and my sympathies on the loss of your father at an age that must have been so difficult. He sounds just like my father-in-law in terms of date screening technique. Now having lived the other side of the coin, I know it was all with the best protective intentions. I think your choice of the word endearing is just about right.

  7. Mina Joshi says:

    Derek – Great article on courtship and wedding. It happens in most in all cultures -except that in some cultures the courtship only happens after the boy has been approved by the girls parents!!I am speaking from an Indian point of view where arranged marriages still take place.

    • DC says:

      Thanks very much Mina. Yes, as much as the world seems to get smaller all the time, there remain some fundamental cultural differences in the customs of marriage. Personally, arranged marriage is a concept I would have difficulty with as a father of daughters. Far too much responsibility. I would much rather offer unsolicited advice, gratuitous guidance, and a thumbs up (or timely frown) from the sidelines. ๐Ÿ™‚

  8. As the mother of three daughters I appreciate your article so much. My oldest is 16 and though the boys in her life are still more like brothers and none has touched her heart in that special way I know that day is not that far away… I worry about so many of the things you bring up… and yet I trust that she will be drawn to someone who will win my heart as well. I feel very protective of my girls as does my husband but for now we’ll enjoy the “brother” types as they come around.

    • DC says:

      Hi Valerie. I have a sense the closer parents are with their children throughout the earlier years, the more acute and aligned the relationship radar when suitors come calling. In our case, it seemed any misgivings we may have had also became at least subtly apparent in our daughters. When the right guy came along (in our minds), it was also a sentiment evident in the girls. We knew they knew we approved. They knew we knew they were happy. I’m not sure if that comes from a history of openness, or blind luck, but I think the talking helps. Thanks very much for your comments and all the best!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Shares
Follow SFW